It should have put the calypso back in Caribbean cricket, celebrating the sport by bringing the game's biggest one-day tournament to countries that know how to throw a party.
Instead, they're despressed from Jamaica to Guyana and from Antigua to St. Kitts. They're fed up with everything from big business interests squashing the spontaneous fun to the lousy performances of the West Indies team and to the mysterious death of Pakistan's English coach Bob Woolmer hours after his team was eliminated in the qualifying round.
The Cricket World Cup, which still has more than three weeks to run, is playing out in grounds where the concrete is still drying, often three-quarters empty and in cities where the populations say they have been promised economic returns in return for sponsoring major building works for stadia and infrastructure.
Most critics have pointed the finger of blame at cricket's administrators.
"The International Cricket Council is ... about making money, having rules, and siding with narrow commercial interests even at the expense of basic human decency, let alone local color. The game's bosses have wrecked their own party with their greed." respected cricket journalist and former Wisden Cricketers' Almanack editor Tim de Lisle wrote.
The ICC has not been willing to address the issues. Chief executive Malcolm Speed, touring media facilities at Guyana's new Providence Stadium, was asked about the problems, but replied: "let's concentrate on watching the cricket shall we?"
Ticket prices as high as US$100, in countries where that kind of money is far out of the reach of ordinary people, have caused outrage. Locals have also been annoyed by rules that mean they cannot walk to the cricket, instead having to take taxis and buses.
Once in the grounds, impromptu party stands that blare out dance music in between overs have been banned and replaced with organized and sanitized versions.
New grounds have been built in Jamaica, Antigua and Guyana to replace crumbling ones that may not have all mod cons but which have made West Indies cricket famous for years. The Bourda in central Georgetown is now a sad relic of its glorious past, while visitors to the gleaming new stadium face a long walk.
"Cricket was always an urban pastime in the West Indies, but the new stadia have changed all that," said former England captain Mike Atherton, a television commentator at the tournament.
Former pace bowler Curtley Ambrose said he felt the ICC had removed the local flavor from the tournament.
"To be hosting the World Cup should be something special. We are a small nation and we should feel proud. In terms of a West Indian flavor, we are used to the music and the cooking under the stands. The prices are ridiculous. In these hard times, it's crazy to ask people to pay 100 U.S. dollars."
In a region where cricket is under constant threat from other sports, fans have voted with their feet and stayed away in big numbers. The shock elimination of cricket giants India and Pakistan was a shock to organizers. Thousands of cricket lovers from the two countries had been expected to fill hotel rooms throughout the region.
Now, home owners who said they redecorated their houses to let them to cricket tourists are complaining they have thrown away the money.
The performance of the West Indies team has added to the general depression.
At their best, Caribbean cricketers set the world on fire, but those days seem to have gone. Now the team appears to be a squabbling travesty of its one-time greatness, split down national lines.
The public has sensed the mood and has not even packed stadia for West Indies matches. Just over half the tickets were sold for West Indies' match against the mighty Australians last week.
Captain Brian Lara was mystified.
"The crowd was very disappointing," said Lara, who top-scored with 77. "You sit back and think every game that West Indies play you expect a full house."
That was the case at the old Recreation Ground situated in the center of Antigua's capital St. John's. While a full crowd there watched Lara score his test record 400 not out against England in 2004, his efforts Wednesday were played out in front of three banks of totally empty temporary seating.
"I don't know what to put my finger upon as the problem," Lara said. "We just focus on the cricket and hope people do come out."
Guyana's President Bharrat Jagdeo leapt to the defense of the World Cup in a televised interview with veteran Caribbean cricket commentator Tony Cozier. "I think people have low expectations of us but we managed to confound all of those who did not expect us to be ready."
He said the ICC had asked Guyana to find 200 volunteers for the event and more than 1,000 had come forward.
